Which histopathological parameter is considered the most reliable prognostic factor in cutaneous melanoma?
Solution
Correct Answer: Option C
- The most reliable histopathological prognostic factor in cutaneous melanoma is the Breslow thickness.
- This measurement refers to the vertical depth of tumor invasion in millimeters, from the granular layer of the epidermis down to the deepest point of tumor penetration.
- It provides a direct quantification of tumor burden and correlates strongly with the risk of metastasis and overall patient survival.
While other factors such as Clark level of invasion, presence of ulceration, and mitotic rate also contribute valuable prognostic information, Breslow thickness remains the cornerstone for staging and prognosis because:
- Clark level is a qualitative assessment based on anatomic skin layer involvement but is less reproducible and less predictive compared to Breslow thickness.
- Ulceration is an important adverse prognostic marker but is typically considered additional information rather than the primary determinant.
- Mitotic rate has prognostic significance, especially in thin melanomas, but does not surpass the predictive value of tumor thickness.
In clinical practice and melanoma staging guidelines (such as the AJCC), Breslow thickness remains the most critical factor guiding treatment decisions and predicting outcomes.
Reference: Robbins & Cotran Pathologic Basis of Disease, 10th Edition, Chapter 9: Tumors of the Skin, p. 1123
- This measurement refers to the vertical depth of tumor invasion in millimeters, from the granular layer of the epidermis down to the deepest point of tumor penetration.
- It provides a direct quantification of tumor burden and correlates strongly with the risk of metastasis and overall patient survival.
While other factors such as Clark level of invasion, presence of ulceration, and mitotic rate also contribute valuable prognostic information, Breslow thickness remains the cornerstone for staging and prognosis because:
- Clark level is a qualitative assessment based on anatomic skin layer involvement but is less reproducible and less predictive compared to Breslow thickness.
- Ulceration is an important adverse prognostic marker but is typically considered additional information rather than the primary determinant.
- Mitotic rate has prognostic significance, especially in thin melanomas, but does not surpass the predictive value of tumor thickness.
In clinical practice and melanoma staging guidelines (such as the AJCC), Breslow thickness remains the most critical factor guiding treatment decisions and predicting outcomes.
Reference: Robbins & Cotran Pathologic Basis of Disease, 10th Edition, Chapter 9: Tumors of the Skin, p. 1123
Practice More Questions on Our App!
Download our app for free and access thousands of MCQ questions with detailed solutions