Directions: Below question is followed by two statements labelled I and II. Decide if these statements are sufficient to conclusively answer the question. Choose the appropriate answer from the options given below:
Is A>B ?
I. A2 + A = ¾ and B2 + 2B = 24
II. A2 – 3A = -9/4 and B2 – 3B = 4
সঠিক উত্তর: Option E
A2 + A = ¾ and B2 + 2B = 24
Solving both the quadratic equations to obtain the roots,
A2 + A = ¾
We can solve this equation using two methods. One is to use formula \(\frac{{ - b \pm \left( {\sqrt {{b^2} - 4ac} } \right)}}{{2a}}\)
or we can solve it by adding a certain number to both sides such that it makes the LHS a perfect square.
In this case, we add ¼ on both sides to make the LHS of the above equation a perfect square.
⇒ A2 + A+ ¼ = ¾ + ¼ ⇒A2 + A+ ¼ = 1
A2 + A + ¼ = (A + ½)2
⇒ (A + ½)2= 1
⇒ A + ½ = ± 1
⇒ A = +1/2 or -3/2
Similarly, for B2 + 2B = 24, we add 1 on both sides,
⇒ B2 + 2B+ 1 = 24 + 1 = 25
⇒ (B + 1)2 = 25
⇒ B + 1 = ± 5 ⇒B = 4 or – 6
The question cannot be answered by using only these two statements, since each of X and Y have two values.
Hence, statement I is insufficient to answer the question.
From statement II:
A2 – 3A = -9/4 and B2 – 3B = 4
We solve these equations in a method similar to the one explained previously.
We add 9/4 on both sides
⇒ A2 – 3A+ (9/4) = (-9/4) + (9/4)
⇒ A2 – 3A+ (9/4) = 0
⇒ (A – (3/2))2 = 0
⇒ A = 3/2
Similarly, B2 – 3B = 4
We add 9/4 on both sides
B2 – 3B+ (9/4) = 4 + (9/4)
⇒ B2 – 3B + (9/4) = 25/4
⇒ (B – (3/2))2 = 25/4
⇒ B – (3/2) = ± 5/2
⇒ B = 4 or –1
Although the value of A is known, the question cannot be answered since B has 2 values, one less than A and the other greater than A.
Combining the two statements we are not able to reach to a conclusion about values of A and B, and hence the relation between them cannot be determined.
The question can not be answered even if both the statements are combined.